As the clock ticks down to January 19th, the fate of TikTok hangs in the balance. The United States Supreme Court is expected to issue a ruling any day now on whether the TikTok ban will proceed, leaving millions of users, brands, and influencers in limbo. But while the legal process plays out, TikTok users are turning to RedNote, or Xiaohongshu, a Chinese social media platform.
The countdown to the TikTok ban
This debate has been years in the making. At the heart of the issue is TikTok’s parent company, ByteDance, based in China. Concerns about national security and the potential for the Chinese government to access vast amounts of personal data from U.S. citizens have sparked calls for a TikTok ban or forced sale. Congress already passed a law mandating that ByteDance either sell the app to a U.S.-based company or shut it down by January 19th—and it was signed into law by President Biden.
Despite the high stakes, the ruling is still pending, and there’s a possibility that the deadline could be extended. But while the U.S. government wrestles with this issue, millions of TikTok users are already jumping ship to RedNote, which is, ironically, controlled by the same Chinese government TikTok critics are trying to avoid.
RedNote: the new home for TikTok’s displaced users
RedNote saw a massive surge in downloads, enough to become the number one downloaded app across both the Apple App Store and Google Play Store. It’s essentially a mirror of TikTok, but with fewer regulations in place. RedNote isn’t even fully accessible to American users yet; the app hasn’t been translated into English, and there’s little to no oversight on the data users provide to the platform. But in the race for an alternative to call home, users seem more than willing to overlook these issues.
The app’s surge in popularity sparks an interesting paradox: the app intended to replace TikTok is controlled by the same entity that caused all of the concerns about data security in the first place. RedNote’s servers are located exclusively in China, making it even more vulnerable to government oversight than TikTok, which stores its data in the U.S. It seems that the U.S. government’s attempt to shield American users from Chinese influence may be backfiring.
What happens next?
For the U.S. government, this is a bit of a dilemma. Can legislators really prevent American users from moving to a platform that aligns with their preferences, even if it poses similar data security risks? If TikTok is banned and users continue moving to RedNote, it will further complicate the government’s efforts to protect data privacy in the digital age.
For TikTok creators and brands, the rise of RedNote poses a problem. If it becomes the go-to platform for American users, brands will need to start from scratch on yet another social media site (one that offers less control over data and privacy). Still, creators shouldn’t make such a significant shift without careful consideration. RedNote’s lack of transparency and the potential risks associated with data privacy and regulation make it a questionable choice for businesses and influencers looking to build sustainable strategies.
Instead, creators and brands should use this period of uncertainty as an opportunity to diversify their social media presence. For those who rely heavily on TikTok, now is the time to actively communicate with their audience, sharing where else they can be found—whether on Instagram, YouTube, or emerging platforms that offer greater security and stability.
The best course of action is preparation. Brands should already be investing in alternative platforms and strategies that resonate with their target audience. If they aren’t diversifying now, they risk being left behind, regardless of TikTok’s fate.
About the authors
Rachel Strella, Founder and CEO of Strella Social Media, celebrates 15 years of success alongside her expert team, offering unmatched expertise in the ever-evolving digital landscape. Strella Social Media has been featured in outlets such as Forbes, Social Media Today, Built In, and Home Business Magazine.
Laney Goff, EVP and TikTok Specialist, is a renowned content creator and influencer with a proven track record of building engaging strategies for clients. Her work has been highlighted in the Scary Mommy Blog, INJOY Success Podcast, and Online Teacher Podcast. Together, Rachel and Laney lead Strella Social Media in delivering innovative solutions and actionable strategies for brands navigating complex social media challenges.
Add Comment